Macon D, on his ever-interesting blog Stuff White People Do, quoted anti-racist writer Shelly Tochluk. Here is a bit of it. She is speaking as a white American:
However, many of us find ourselves looking at other groups and longing for the connection we imagine they feel with their roots, their homeland, their culture. Many white folks can be heard saying, “We don’t have culture. They have culture.”
…
I know that I am not alone. I hear the same sentiments too much from other white people. If anything, this is one of the truest hallmarks of whiteness that I have yet encountered. There is a hole within many of us, created when our families gave up our culture in order to be successful in the United States.
Heartfelt and honest, no doubt, but it is still maddening to hear it.
A lost homeland? Their homeland is made up of the lost homelands of others: the United States of America.
No rootedness? They live in a country – in a world! – where their culture is top dog. Where their culture is taught in schools across the country and shown on televisions round the world. Where their food and drink is sold in the four corners of the earth! How much more rooted can you be?
Lack of a culture? They have one of the most powerful cultures in history, like the Romans, the Persians and the Chinese, one that threatens other cultures.
White Americans have a culture just like everyone else: they have strange holidays and special foods, they have their own way of dressing, of talking, of family life, their own feelings about dogs, their own ideas about music, female beauty, skin colour and disciplining children. They have their own books, songs, television shows and films. They have blue jeans, rock music and hamburgers. Baseball and Starbucks.
They have their own language, which is taught in every school in the land as “proper English”. White Americans even speak English with an accent – which they call “having no accent”.
Whatever old ways Tochluk’s family lost from the old country they were replaced by their White American counterparts. It is how they lost their foreignness. The hole was filled. It had to be. How else can she sing and dance and talk and cook and tell stories to her children?
Many white Americans seem to see themselves as plain, ordinary and boring. “Generic”, I think, is the word. It is everyone else who is different, interesting, colourful or “exotic”.
Well, that is a point of view. They are so used to their own culture, like water to a fish or refrigerator noises, they take it so much for granted, it is so much a part of what they think of as “being a normal person”, that they do not see it. Just like how they do not hear their own accent – or see themselves as “white”.
See also:
- The Shelly Tochluk quote in full at the blog Stuff White People Do
- Other reactions:
- “White people have no culture” – about Tochluk’s confusion of culture with race
- “White people have no culture” – about Tochluk’s confusion of culture with race
- White people think people of colour have more culture
- White American culture
- white people
- white privilege
- How white people think
- acceptable blackness
- A Guide to Anglos
Thanks for the shoutout, Abagond. Yes, it’s maddening all right, and I think you go along way here toward explaining both some ways that whites actually do have a fairly common culture among themselves (though such other factors as social class and geographic region mess with the idea of a common white American culture), and why whites think they don’t–why it’s not labeled, in their minds, “white.” Just for the record, Tochluk’s book makes it clear that she finds this maddening too, and so do I.
LikeLike
I agree almost-wholeheartedly with your assessment, Aba. But I have to agree with the original author’s assessment in a way: there is no such thing as a common white culture. Sure, maybe in stereotypical ways. But that’s just that: stereotypes. Not authentically defined, just perception. Same with the idea of “acting black”, what’s that? That’s just as maddening as what you and the original author are saying about the existance of white culture.
LikeLike
I love your articles but I have to disagree. The culture you speak of is an American culture…not a white culture. Its comprised of a blending of european cultures,and every other ethnic group that comes to the US. My father is from the south and chicken friend steak, grits, fried okra etc…was part of my californian upbreaking…along with sushi, papusas and lasagna. I think of myself as an all american girl. I listen to classical, country, hip hop, jazz, R&B, rock, salsa and pretty much anything else.
I think I can find something in common with anyone I meet – white is not a culture, its a race. You could be white and born in africa or you could be ‘black’ and be belgian, english, french, german, russian, scottish etc. I am American. My ancestors were American Indians, Germans and Scotts. My brother in law is American and his ancestors come from arica and latin america.
To define my self as simiply “white” would be to limit myself. And now that I think about it…”american girl” is limiting…I am…Davida..Made up of all my life experiences, good or bad, wife, mother, butterfly and gypsy child…all of that and more…we shouldnt limit ourselves with labels.
LikeLike
sorry about typos above – I can NOT type on a straight keyboard.
LikeLike
I think she’s right White Americans are culturally challenged, everything that you call culture either it came from other countries and was slightly modified or is a very weak cultural manifestation, you cannot compare the cultural manifestations of the Romans and the Chinese with the Americans. it’s like comparing gold to lead.
LikeLike
I know some whites are made uneasy by calling anything “white”, but the fact is white Americans share a common culture that is different than black American culture. Racism is a part of that culture. It is important to see this. It is also American and not just white in the sense that it is different than British or French culture. Thus “white American”.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Two points:
First, no culture is pure. The Romans took things from the Greeks, Egyptians and Babylonians. The Chinese took from the Manchus, Mongols and now the West. A strong culture will do that. It is not concerned about losing its soul, its supposed purity. Only threatened cultures think that way.
Second, the people who live in a culture are all different. They think for themselves, they have different experiences. They are not mindless, culturally programmed robots; they are not living stereotypes. And, this being America, many have experience of other cultures: “My parents came from …, I grew up in a … neighbourhood, I went to a … school, now I live in ….”. Etc.
So:
American culture is a big mash up, because Americans themselves come from all over and mix together, just like with Davida, but that does not mean there is not some common culture shared by the broad mainstream of the country. In fact, outside of certain cities, like New York, San Francisco, Miami and Los Angeles, the country has a sickening sameness.
Most of what you see on American television is part of that common culture. And most of us know that that mainstream is way way more white than black, far more Anglo than Latin, far more Protestant than Catholic, Muslim or Jewish.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Abagond, I see Macon’s point being that “white” culture is bland and here, tied to country rather than race.
LikeLike
Macon D: I am glad Tochluk saw it as maddening too. From what you quoted of her in your blog post I would have never bought her book.
LikeLike
There is no unified white American culture. The distinction Agabond fails to draw is that between a culture — an identified set of behaviors, beliefs, mannerisms, etc. that a group uses to self-identify among themselves a certain kinship — and socioeconomic hegemony that accompanies majority status.
This is why whites divide ourselves into sub-cultures: Jewish Americans; NASCAR fans; triathletes. It is natural to seek fellowship among a larger group of like-minded and like-natured humans.
Many whites are not born into such a sub-culture. Davida’s example is one. Sub-cultural identity was sacrificed by parents and grandparents chasing the American dream through their diaspsora. Thus, many white people themselves searching for a sub-culture with which to identify.
The drive to be a part of a legitimate culture is deeply ingrained in human nature. It explains, among other things, why gangs form.
Did you know, by the way, that “Jim Morrison” is an anagram for “Mr. Mojo Risin”?
LikeLike
Macon D: I am glad Tochluk saw it as maddening too. From what you quoted of her in your blog post I would have never bought her book.
Then I’m glad I clarified that. I thought it was clear that she was describing an earlier, more naive version of herself, but I can see how readers of my post would take it the way you did. I also thought that she describes well the idea of a cultural gap or “hole” felt by some whites, and how they try to fill it with apparent cultural forms other than something they see as “white culture.” They do so because, if something like that exists, they don’t see it as “white culture.”
LikeLike
I wouldnt say I wasnt born into one.
I am a southern baptist ministers daughter, a cops daughter and an army warrent officers daughter. My niece is mixed race and I think she should cherish all of her sub cultures.
My sister and I took her to a recent exhibit at the de young museum of Quilt art done by african american women of the tennesee hills – beautiful, I take her to the scottish games, to german folk festivals and Cynco De mayo celebrations. The art of all the cultures is amazing and beautiful. The music is wounderful. I just hate to see people limit themselves…instead of embrace all that they are and expand themselves by learning from everyone they meet. To define my self simiply as a nascar person (my husband races road race cars) or a mountain girl or whatever is to limit myself in life. I take belly dancing and love to dance to african and aribic drums, I box to salsa and latin beats, I sing blues, R&B, country – what ever strikes a cord with me.
I once had an english professor that was black. She had lived through the civil rights movement and had reason for some of her behavior – however expressed anti “white” opinions on a daily basis. We had to write an essay on someone we admire, and not put our names on the paper. She would grade the paper and then try to guess who she thought wrote it. I wrote about billie holiday. She guessed every single person of color first. When I finally told her I had written it she said that it was impossible…that a white person coldnt write about billie holidays life and music like I had…that white people dont feel the soul and movement of music like black people do. I was the only A she had given. Any person with even the tiniest drop of empathy can feel the injustice and pain she experienced in her life. My skin colors does not define me…I truelly believe this. Who I am inside does.
LikeLike
Firstly. it’s true that the Chinese took from the Manchus and the Mongols but they imposed their cultural identity over those nations besides they developed their own cultural uniqueness their influence over the Chinese is very weak. Chinese culture is more than 2000 years old, it takes time to form a cultural identity. their cultural influence is very diverse (philosophy)(religion)(artworks)(poetry)(monuments)(traditions) the contributions to the west and the east are many. The Romans being the dominant power took from the Greeks, but it adopted more from the Greek culture (their gods, democracy etc) than the other way around. they too made contributions to the west and the east (the roman law code). In short no culture is pure but they developed their own cultural uniqueness. that’s what it means to have a culture.
Secondly. too many times I’ve heard Americans talking about being cultural threatened being cultural self-centered without fully understanding what it means to have a culture (ex what’s wrong with building a supermarket near an archeological? site it’s only a building! that’s a good example of cultural insensitivity).
You are talking about set of beliefs, mannerisms, behaviors, that is not culture. being an individual with your own set of beliefs, personality, temperament doesn’t mean that we don’t share cultural roots and heritage. it takes cultural appreciation and understanding to preserve another culture (for example preserving customs, languages, monuments, archeologycal sites)(Peru, Mexico, Bolivia are good examples)(China is trying to do something about it too)
Free-trade, economic empowerment, individuality, ideals, all of those are American traits, none of them are cultural manifestations. I suggest you the next time you travel to a foreign country learn it’s history and try to bathe into it’s culture. if it weren’t for the gens des couleur (all the blacks in all the U.S) the U.S would be a totally bland culturally challenged country.
Cultural contributions I thank you for: Jazz and Blues.
LikeLike
A good book on this topic is
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nine_Nations_of_North_America
The book basically states that America does not have one culture but 9. The book was published in the early 80’s so some of the info may be dated, but still a good read.
PS
I am a first time poster, but this is one my favorite blogs to read. Unlike so many other blogs, this blog is devoted to working hard to finding the best understanding of whatever the given topic is, rather than dealing with a few egomaniacs POV.
Nice job, abagond.
LikeLike
“Rock music”.
Abagond, I do not think of White people when I think of rock music.
I think of Black people:
-The Mills Brothers
-Little Richard
-Ike Turner
-Etta James
-Chuck Berry
-Bo Diddley
I do not consider rock music the sole domain and creation of White people. Rock music has its roots in blues, rhythm and blues, and even gospel. Whites who came along and “took” it over—-Elvis Presley (NOT the King of Rock and Roll; Pat Boone), and either watered it down of changed it altogether, are not the sole creators of rock music. Though some White musicians did add a different style to the original rhythm and blues aspect, (“rockabilly”, country and western), the basic foundation of rock music rests on Black input, creativity and style.
Only when Alan Freed started playing Black people’s rock music as a Cleveland DJ in 1951, DID rock music cross over into the world of Whites; back then, it was called race music when used to categorize Black people’s music (thus introducing Black American music to a wider audience: Whites, Latinos, Native Americans—-the world.) In fact, the phrase “rocking and rolling”, was secular black slang for dancing or sex, and the phrase first appeared on a record for the first time in 1922 on Trixie Smith’s “My Man Rocks Me With One Steady Roll”.
“Rockin'” was also a term used by Black churches/gospel singers in the American South to mean something akin to spiritual ecstasy—“getting happy”, “shouting”.
There are many who consider the “first” rock-n-roll song to be Ike Turner and his band the Kings of Rhythm: “Rocket 88”, first performed in 1951.
Other forms of rock and roll that came along decades later, were progressive rock, alternative rock, acid rock, punk rock, and heavy metal, to name just a few.
So, you see, I take offense (not to you 🙂 when people give all the credit of the creation of rock and roll to White musicians.
Before rock and roll, before rhythm and blues, before blues, before ragtime, there were “Negro” sprituals. Black music IS America’s gift to the world. I know many people will say that White musicians have contributed to rock music, and they have. But, I do not want for people to continue to regard rock and roll as a sole creation of White people when its true origins began with Black people.
The same goes for Bluegrass music.
When I think of Bluegrass music, I do not think of White people. I think of Black people:
-The Carolina Chocolate Drops
Not Bill Monroe and the Bluegrass Boys.
He and his group became famous for bluegrass music, but, forgotten and disregarded are the many Black creators of original, authentic, bluegrass music. The various types of music combined with the people who began migrating to America in the early 1600s are considered to be the roots of bluegrass music—including dance music and ballads from Ireland, Scotland and England, as well as Black American gospel music and blues. (In fact, slaves from Africa brought the design idea for the banjo–an instrument now integral to the bluegrass sound.)
Yes, Bluegrass is music that is lively and fast..
It is “musician’s music”.
It is music from the heart and soul.
Bluegrass like jazz, gospel, blues—is truly an American music. Bluegrass is an amlgamation of country music (which also has Black American roots), Anglo-Celtic music, Appalachian folk music, and most of all, Black American Jazz and Blues, and Ragtime music.
If not for the enormous contributions of Black Americans:
-Civil Rights Movement (Diane Nash, “Mama” Dolly Raines, Mrs. Silas McGhee, Unita Blackwell, Fannie Lou Hamer, Ella Baker)
-Labor Movement (Mamma Harris, Lucy Parsons, Black Washerwomen Movement of 1866)
-Black feminists (Fannie Barrier Williams, Sojourner Truth)
-The fight against sexism (Kathleen Cleaver, Elaine Brown)
-Law (Florence Kennedy)
to name just a few. . . .
. . . .America would be a poorer place indeed.
Shelly Tochluk:
“There is a hole within many of us, created when our families gave up our culture in order to be successful in the United States.”
Indeed, there is.
Many ethnic Whites who sought to become “American” who worked their way through the wages of “whiteness” to “become white” gave up much culture—and humanity to become white. When they arrived in America, Irish, Poles, Italians, etc., were considered “in-between”—neither “White” nor “Black”. But, they paid a terrible price, along with their racial assaults upon their fellow Black citizens (Chicago Riot of 1919 [Irish]; Springfield Massacre of 1885 [Italians]; East St. Louis Riot of 1917 [Irish] to become “white”.
Once they became white, there was no going back, no reclaiming what so many had jettisoned to earn the wages of whiteness and to leave forever the connection to “blackness” if they had stayed allies with Black people.
LikeLike
What’s with the picture of Jim Morrison?
LikeLike
Wow, thanks Ann!
I know that rock music came from black music. You cannot listen to, say, Stevie Ray Vaughn or Led Zeppelin and not know that. And I know that it is not just whites who listen to it. But rock is, for all that, a part of the white culture.
I did not know about the black roots of bluegrass.
I do not know about how Italians, etc, became “white”, except in very general terms, but I imagined it was not pretty, like you say.
LikeLike
Jim Morrison: because he is near-naked, as in being supposedly cultureless and yet he is himself a famous white American who contributed to their culture. I hope that makes sense.
LikeLike
I have heard of the 9 Nations book. Thanks for the recommendation.
Another good book in this vein, but a way heavier read, is “Albion’s Seed” by David Hackett Fischer. It is about how American society grew out of not one England but four different Englands:
1629-1640: East Anglia -> New England
1640-1675: southern England -> the South
1675-1725: North Midlands -> Pennsylvania
1717-1775: Northumbria -> Appalachia
LikeLike
You are welcome, Abagond, always a pleasure 😉
Now that I have posted here, this has given me the impetus to put up my post I have been meaning to start:
“On This Day In Black Music History”.
Thanks for the great post.
LikeLike
The answer is obviously yes but what is the nature of that culture?
The central issues of White Culture are as follows:
1) Self definition in terms of Negatives – not Positives;
2) lack of Cultural Validity;
3) reality evasion;
4) blandness;
5) false unity.
Whites think They have no culture because They do not use the qualifying adjective White when They talk about culture – as in White Culture. However, the only exception is that this is never true when Whites talk about race – as in White Race.
The idea that Whites have no culture really means Whites define Their culture solely in negatives. Negatives such as not being like those non Whites murdered to create the US in the first place – a homeland They know is not rightfully Theirs. Not having great music nor great athletes, not wanting to listen to (or even see) Blacks. In other words, a culture based on guilt as well as the superficialities, such as ways of talking, pets, blue jeans, rock music, hamburgers, baseball and Starbucks.
Whites feel a sense of rootlessness because, although Their culture is widespread, it is widespread precisely because such widespreadedness is an attempt to valorise such a superficial culture by spreading it thinly. This, instead of rooting it more deeply in the soil in fewer geographical areas. As when someone does not really believe what they are saying, because they have no evidence to back it up. They then tend either to raise their voice and/or to make personal attacks to compensate for the intellectual, moral and experiential emptiness of their comments.
That a culture is powerful is not proof of the validity of such a culture. Again, Whites use power as a solace for Their ethical emptiness rather than as proof of Their cultural rootedness. The use of power without an enemy is always the mark of the insecure who can achieve anything by no other means. It proves Whites have no culture other than through the use of naked force. White attempts to destroy other cultures are really fits of jealous rage when confronted with something that is built upon much firmer rocks and is therefore destined to be longer lasting.
The basic problem US Blacks have is that They have no culture independent of Whites because They were cut off from Their African roots. At least the Natives still have access to their heritage because They still live on the lands of their fathers. This is why, for example, Whites today claim that there were no civilisations in Africa before White men went there despite the mass of archaeological evidence to the contrary. Whites want to believe Blacks have no culture to justify slavery and racism. The partial solution here is to utilise what is good from White culture and reject the rest.
Whites feel threatened by the depth and breadth of other cultures because Their own is so lacklustre by comparison. Look at how self-confident south Asians are. Despite the relatively short-lived intrusion of the British Empire, Asians possess a culture going back thousands of years to largely explain that self-confidence. The reverse is true for most Whites whose genealogy will not go back more than 500 years.
The items listed as markers of White culture are actually markers of what was appropriated from other cultures, especially Whites’ major religion being a Levantine import and not indigenous/endogenous to Their culture. Whites have tried to get around this fact of their essential paganism by pictorially claiming biblical characters, especially Jesus and God were/are White. The same is true for Their language (originally Sanskrit) and numbering system (Arabic). Whites have made these things part of Their culture precisely because they fill a hole that was there to begin with. White cultural appropriation continues in the absence of Their inability to deepen Their own culture so that ethnic minorities now provide the best US entertainment. That Whites flock to consume such material proves the lack in Themselves. When Whites mimic such music, we end up with Elvis Presley, Slim Shady and The Rolling Stones – literally pale imitations of their antecedents. This shows where Whites are lacking in crucial areas that They have to copy others to make up for the dearth. The only new White musical form was punk rock – that expresses nothing more than White anger at a culture that offers Them little more than the opportunity to copy others rather than articulate something authentically White.
White authenticity is essentially racism – like the KKK – and there is no doubting the depth of their race hatred and the sincerity of such groups in this regard. Whites would prefer to conceal this bedrock racism as much as possible; meaning that for Whites to be accepted as Whites they have to renounce their humanity (by becoming racist) in order to benefit from the resulting White privilege. This is not only to avoid being treated like Blacks – who are always shown to other groups as examples of what will happen if you do not conform to Whiteness – but also to create a culture of false unity. A false unity that is based not on shared values – Whites possess no deep-seated values – but on mutually agreed hate. If Whites hated no one, Their culture would collapse because then the hate filled cement that keeps it together would vanish. This counterfeit harmony also helps avoid being labelled as “Nigger Lovers” and of being treated as badly as Blacks are.
These serious White culture gaps are filled with a culture that lacks pride in itself because of the inherent fear of others built in. This is done just in case Their shallowness is seen; hence, the loud audio volume of Their culture because empty vessels make the most noise. The racist responses to your own blog reveal how loudly White racists proclaim Their self proclaimed ethical right to be racist while never once advancing a moral argument to sustain such a position. The fact that Whites see Themselves as “generic” (ie, to have transcended a Whiteness that was never used as a negative accusation against Them) proves that They are trying to be seen as a universal culture. A culture that everyone else should aspire to in order to avoid the nagging sense that Whites are essentially superficial. This explains why Whites spent so many centuries exporting a religion They did not believe in, to what we now call the Third World. And why They now try to spread the pseudo religion of democracy and feminism abroad when oligarchy and sexism are rife in their own countries. The fact that They must use violence in spreading Their culture means They know others will not willingly accept it.
Such inappropriate aggression is also based on the ultimate hope that if everyone else is made in Their own image, there would then be no-one around to criticise Them since then all criticism would be silenced. This is the ultimate goal of claiming Whites are better than others – concealing moral emptiness by trying to destroy those that point it out. The same was true of the Roman Empire that has given us little of any lasting value to admire except their military prowess. And yet that is the empire Whites model Themselves on not, for example, the more intellectual Phoenicians nor the more spiritual ancient Egyptians.
Another issue for White culture is that Whites are unwilling to share what little culture They possess. They are frightened that others will come to see Them as They truly are if They do. A culture unwilling to share resorts to boastfulness as a vain substitute for a pride that likes to share itself with others and become self valorising in the process. But since Whites have historically done much for which They are now guilt ridden and ashamed, They pretend Their culture is superior and that only equally superior people are allowed in. That is, only those who share the same guilt feelings They can empathise with. This is the quintessential sense of inferiority to Blacks that Whites feel since Whites know that Blacks do not feel guilty about racism. This, despite various White attempts to make Blacks feel such guilt by claiming, for example, that Blacks are as racist as Whites.
Whites see Their own political imperfections very clearly. Whites are not blind to Their own racism since when you point it out to Them, They become very angry that you have done so; proving that you have struck a raw (not a hidden) nerve. Whites hope others will not notice: They simply do not wish to be reminded of what They already know. After all, every man knows where his own shoes pinch. To get around this metaphysical problem, Whites preach substantive issues as if They were a fundamental part of Their culture: Capitalism, democracy & individuality, for example. But these are only practised when it suits Whites, so that each should realistically be prefixed with the word “White” when used – White Capitalism, White Democracy & White individuality.
Most talk about whether Whites have a culture avoid the points made here; leading to much confusion about what the question really means. Modern Whites do have a culture but it lacks roots (not having been around long) and a moral centre (being materialistic); explaining why social hypocrisy is so common in the West and all the other disproportionate ills it leads to. These are child molestation, pornography, divorce, adultery, motiveless murder, loveless sex, sexism, racism, classism, emotional repression, etc.
The other issue with White culture is its blandness: Country & western and folk music are a joke. Actually talking to a White gives one the strong sense that one is talking to the persona and not the character and that one is learning about Them rather than from Them. Their often lack of overt body language and speech modulations only strengthens this impression. Cultural discourse is limited to what benefits Whites. When others claim equal treatment from Whites, They become hysterically angry and pretend equality has always existed and that Blacks are merely “playing the race card” to get special privileges not open to Whites.
Although many alien elements are now firmly part of White culture, they never lost their alienness (it is still possible to trace their origins) because they could never become deeply rooted in a culture that, itself, lacks deep roots.
LikeLike
To Frank Talker:
Their language (originally Sanskrit)
Presumably you meant written language. The Latin alphabet is derived from the a Greek alphabet which is partially derived from a Phoenician trade language which influenced multiple alphabets. So it is not from Sanskrit. And when you say “Their language” you would also mean my language since you are writing in English.
As for culture you totally ignored Fine Art (dominated by the West for over a hundred years..) Cinema (Ditto..) Television (Ditto..) Ballet, Opera, Classical music and huge body of literature and philosophy that have been published in the last 500 years. A good chunk of the sports that are played today have so called white origins some exceptions would be basketball (possible Mesoamerican origins although not in it’s current form..)
A collection of authors in 1999 who write in Arabic lamented that there were more novels published in one country Ireland (with just over 4 million people) in the last decade than in all Arabic speaking countries. (about 280 million people)
White attempts to destroy other cultures are really fits of jealous rage when confronted with something that is built upon much firmer rocks and is therefore destined to be longer lasting.
Then you haven’t read what most white conquerors wrote.. they clearly thought that their culture was superior and were trying in their minds to “civilize” what they felt were inferior cultures. I do not agree with that attitude but reading the journals of explorers hardly gives one idea that they thought they were encountering a superior longer lasting culture. (An exception would be Alexander the Great of Greece conquering Persian..Alexander clearly thought the Persians had a superior if not decadent culture..) Injecting your opinion into an argument doesn’t make it so.
Their often lack of overt body language and speech modulations only strengthens this impression.
Are you a comedian..? Have you even been to Japan or China…? Or do you think those countries were they are less likely to express physical emotion than your average white European or American lack a culture..?
Another issue for White culture is that Whites are unwilling to share what little culture They possess.
Another joke, American TV and Cinema are pervasive. How is it white folks are somehow not sharing a culture with non-white folks. I know a number of non-white folks who believe (not necessarily intentionally) are shoving white culture down their throats. (That to some degree is what Abagond discusses in this blog if you care to check…)
By the way you might want to look up who invented most parts of the computer and the concept of the internet so you could project your opinion. Inventions (predominantly) by whites have decidedly changed the transmission and distribution of culture.
LikeLike
There is most definitely a white culture, and Abagond hits the nail on the head by noting that white Americans perceive themselves as “standard” or “normal” and everyone else has “cultural differences.” In places like Hawaii where white Americans are the minority, the whites are very conscious of being just another ethnicity, and they’re quite comfortable with it. On the mainland, white Americans are just too insulated to know that they have a culture, and since their culture is largely consumer culture, they don’t really have something distinctive to identify with that is easy to differentiate from American exports abroad that soon become “generic”. Food-wise, Americans have their own culture. If you go to certain sports pubs, brunch places, most places with some Anglo origins, then the customers there will be extremely skewed toward being white. So, obviously, these kinds of places are distinctive to their culture. Also, if you see the people coming back from Yankee games on the subway in New York, it is really striking how they look really different from the usual mix of people on the subway — it’s weird to see a large number of all white people who look like they came from the suburbs. Also, architecturally, if you go to neighborhoods that are heavily white — like in diverse California, the neighborhoods sort themselves out ethnically — the rich, old white places always feel very clean and sterile and uniform, whereas the hipster young white places will be grungey (maybe in rebellion against the rich white places), and the blue collar white places have mostly unhealthy, processed food to eat in desolate strip malls. Maybe what gives Anglo white culture the having-no-culture mentality is that the class-based cultural origins from England were feudal in which the peasantry really were poor and had little chance for cultural development, whereas in, say, Latin America, Africa, and Asia, there was no class-based society so even the poorest people have their own handicrafts, dances, and fairly well-developed cuisine. But one also has to distinguish popular culture from high culture: Western classical music and art from Europe are rich cultural traditions that are ever developing. But these are also fine art that perhaps transcends cultural boundaries, and with globalization and the mixing of intellectuals from the various continents, the various intellectual and cultural traditions have been mixing and melding in new expressive forms. So, when we are talking about what distinguishes white American culture, we are really talking primarily about pop culture.
LikeLike
Kirv said:
“Also, if you see the people coming back from Yankee games on the subway in New York, it is really striking how they look really different from the usual mix of people on the subway — it’s weird to see a large number of all white people who look like they came from the suburbs.”
I noticed that too.
LikeLike
the blue collar white places have mostly unhealthy, processed food to eat in desolate strip malls.
I hate strip malls with a passion.
LikeLike
Folks, that’s called ethnocentrism and everybody has it to one degree or another. Faced with Brazilians, American blacks consider themselves “standard and normal”. Brazilians are either highly exotic or backwards.
This may indeed be a white trait, but it is also avery American one.
LikeLike
Kirv:
But one also has to distinguish popular culture from high culture…So, when we are talking about what distinguishes white American culture, we are really talking primarily about pop culture.
************
I think that’s what “some” white (american) people mean when they say they don’t have “culture”. There is plenty of pop – culture but no one notices it because it’s normalized and exported around the world but The supposed absence of uber-bourgeoisie “high culture” with the “special, sacred, mystical” dances, etc.
LikeLike
One of few surprising things I’ve learned here is that rock is considered “white” music. I never, never thought about it that way. And no, I don’t mean in “neutral” white gaze sort of way (“I don’t think of it as white, I think it’s just normal”). With so many black (and non-black) musicians and fans out there, and with the whole history or rock n roll, I never thought it might be considered a white thing.
Then again, maybe my circle of (Internet) friends isn’t the best one to describe “average American group” of people.
I don’t see Jim Morrison as the best example of “white American culture”, but he’ll do.
LikeLike
I haven’t read all the other comments, so I may be repeating here. I can see both sides, but as a whitey, I have to disagree a little with your assessment – my feelings are in line with Shelley. *I* do not have a culture, unless I *choose* to fall in line with American society – I don’t celebrate “Christmas” like other white people might, I don’t support monolingualism, etc. In fact, looking at the detriment people with my skin color have caused other races forces me into further seclusion, because I’m ashamed to be a part of the white group. Further, I disagree with so much of mainstream American “culture.” I feel like it’s as racially-charged to lump all white people into one culture (American) as it is to lump every black person in North America into “black culture.” So in that sense, maybe Shelley’s off too – unless she’s talking about small, distinct groups.
“White” culture is also perceived to be made of ignorance, and I can agree with that. But there are lots of white people out there trying to fight what mainstream society has been telling us for 200 years and bridge barriers. I know white people have a lot to make up for, but there are those of us who don’t feel apart of American society (and, therefore, according to some comments here, white culture).
Our predecessors have screwed over every other race to the point that many of them don’t want to connect with us, and a lot of us hate being around ignorant white people who don’t know shit from shit. So in that sense, yeah, we feel pretty disconnected.
LikeLike
Why do you call yourself a “whitey”? Is it an ethnic slur or what? What does it mean?
LikeLike
Many white folks can be heard saying, “We don’t have culture. They have culture.”
It seems to me that people who say this don’t have the slightest clue as to what “culture” is.
Lack of a culture? They have one of the most powerful cultures in history, like the Romans, the Persians and the Chinese, one that threatens other cultures.
Likewise people who say this.
Both groups seem to believe that “culture” is some ineffable essence, passed down in the blood, which is somehow congruent with race and/or nationality.
Let’s get this straight, folks: first of all no one “has” a culture. Cultures, like languages, are not physcial objects but symbolic constructs. Either you learn to participate in them or you don’t. You do not “have” a culture nor can anyone “steal” your culture, just like speaking English doesn’t mean you “have” English and neither does a new English speaker steal anything from you, an old English speaker.
With that in mind, so-called “white” people participate in many different cultures. There is no one “white” culture just like there is no one “English” langauge.
You’d think people would look up the scientific definition of “culture” before commenting on it, neh?
LikeLike
It seems to me that people who say this don’t have the slightest clue as to what “culture” is.
And anthropologists do? 😉
LikeLike
Hell, at least we know what it ISN’T. 😀
LikeLike
I agree with this post. There is a white American culture but it’s so ubiquitous and dominant that it’s difficult to recognize or articulate. That’s why some white Americans think they don’t have a culture and often identify themselves with what they consider their most distinctive ancestry (Irish or Italian in many cases).
LikeLike
“There is a white American culture but it’s so ubiquitous and dominant that it’s difficult to recognize or articulate.”
Not only that but it it’s so vast it fails to serve the basic function of culture. Facilitating interaction. We all share the same culture yet still have nothing in common with one another. That’s why we feel culture-less even though we are not.
LikeLike
@ jas0n
Ooh…good one.
There’s nothing empowering about it. It does not help with defining identity.
LikeLike
@ Ank,
do you mean collective identity? then yes I agree. Whites don’t feel connected to one another by any sense of identity.
For example I can’t assume that the white guy next to me on the bus has anything in common with me. he might listen to different music, have a different diet, dress differently, does he like sports? which ones? what slang does he use if any? politics? education? class background? etc.
White culture is like a buffet with a million options. It reminds me of my high school cafeteria. I imagine that the black students sitting at their group of tables would look around and just see a bunch of white people. Meanwhile we would look at each other and see. The jocks, the nerds, the preps, the punks, the hippies, etc. All having no more in common with each other than with the black students.
LikeLike
“There is no forest, just trees….”
LikeLike
jas0n,
“do you mean collective identity? then yes I agree…we look at each other and see the jocks, the nerds, the preps, the punks, the hippies, etc. All having no more in common with each other than with the black students.”
Isn’t this a good thing?
This is part of white privilege: not having to be defined by your perceived race. You can speak and act for yourself, rather than being a symbol for all people that look remotely similar to you.
And yet most whites do feel connected to each other by perceived race; this is proven by their reactions to any and all comments about white people, even if they are specifically excluded.
LikeLike
“Isn’t this a good thing?
This is part of white privilege: not having to be defined by your perceived race. You can speak and act for yourself, rather than being a symbol for all people that look remotely similar to you. ”
Sure, it’s great to be seen as an individual I suppose. But is there really such a thing? Isn’t that a western idea in itself? We all want to be individuals yet we need commonalities to form connections. Like goths who call themselves non-conformists yet they all dress exactly the same.
@abagond
I’m not saying we don’t have a culture. We do. I’m just saying our culture is useless because it’s to vast. It has so many different meanings it’s meaningless.
Anyone familiar with the story of the tower of Bable from The Bible? It’s like that. We speak so many languages (figuratively) we can’t understand one another.
LikeLike
jas0n,
“Sure, it’s great to be seen as an individual I suppose. But is there really such a thing?”
Yes, why not?
“We all want to be individuals yet we need commonalities to form connections.”
Having a few, random commonalities doesn’t negate individuality, does it?
LikeLike
“And yet most whites do feel connected to each other by perceived race; this is proven by their reactions to any and all comments about white people, even if they are specifically excluded.”
yeah, but our race only exists to us in the presence of non- whites. Unless we try to make it matter.
LikeLike
jas0n,
“I’m not saying we don’t have a culture. We do. I’m just saying our culture is useless because it’s to vast. It has so many different meanings…”
I hear some whites say this, and it seems self-congratulating. So, other people are just a monolith with one culture? And only whites have so many different cultures? I seriously have heard whites say that there is one black culture, with many “branches”, while claiming whites have a plethora of cultures that can’t be given a label. Those were “WTF?” moments, to the max. Check your privilege… it seeps out in the most seemingly innocuous statements.
LikeLike
“I hear some whites say this, and it seems self-congratulating.”
LOL. yay we did it!
LikeLike
“So, other people are just a monolith with one culture?”
No, American non-white’s are no more or less individuals than white people. But they do have less expansive cultures.
LikeLike
jas0n,
“No, American non-white’s are no more or less individuals than white people. But they do have less expansive cultures.”
How so?
*Lol, this is exactly how the last culture conversation I had started out*
LikeLike
Ha! The most loaded question ever. “Tell me about my culture white person”
LikeLike
First of all, there seems to be a basic misunderstanding of the word “culture” going on here.
“Culture” does not mean an identity or an ethnicity. Nor is identity necessarily empowering. Neither is individuality for that matter.
Secondly, people do not “have” cultures: they practice them. Cultures are like languages. They are not objects which can be stolen, appropriated or alienated. They can be practiced or not. One can encourage or discourage their practice. Typically, the world over, when one tries to discourage a cultural practice by a given people, this ENCOURAGES the formation of ethnicity and the recreation of culture.
Third, cultures are not thousands or hundreds of years old: they are recreated every single day, always with new things coming in and old things dropping by the wayside. They are thus a bit like living organisms.
To thus talk about “white culture” or “black culture” presumes a whole series of things that are just not true. I would encourage people, whenever they feel the need to use the word “culture”, tyo substitute “language” and see if it still makes sense.
Is there white and black English? Not really. There are white and black dialects of English, many on both sides of the colour line. And plenty of black people know how to speak white dialects and vice versa.
Thus with culture. It’s plural, amorphous, non-binding. It has no strict congruencies to ethnicity, nation, ort race, although there are national, ethnic and racial patterns to it. Culture divides as much as it connects, separates as much as it joins.
And one can manifestly have pluralist cultures, which is what “U.S. culture” and most of what Jason would probably call “black” or “white” cultures are.
LikeLike
jas0n,
Ha! The most loaded question ever. “Tell me about my culture white person”
What? 🙂
I’d be interested to know, really.
Above it seemed like you were implying that blacks don’t have their own jocks, nerds, hippies, etc. I’ve never heard anyone, white or otherwise, imply such. The black nerds who comment here would not be impressed by that suggestion!
‘And one can manifestly have pluralist cultures, which is what “U.S. culture” and most of what Jason would probably call “black” or “white” cultures are.’
I do think U.S. culture is a conglomeration of many different cultures, but many people I’ve met think U.S./American culture = white culture.
LikeLike
“Above it seemed like you were implying that blacks don’t have their own jocks, nerds, hippies, etc. ”
Not at all. I know better.
But there is still a collective identity. Black people identify as black. Think of themselves as black. Recognize one another as black. (obviously among other things)
Whites do not do this. So we have jocks, nerds ect. JUST LIKE EVERYONE ELSE. But without an overarching collective identity that binds us. Simply because we are the dominant majority.
Being white doesn’t mean anything to white people. We are seen as a group by others but do not see ourselves as a group. Even though we are.
LikeLike
Natasha,
I do think U.S. culture is a conglomeration of many different cultures, but many people I’ve met think U.S./American culture = white culture.
Very true. Things like hot dogs, fast food, etc., I think of as textbook American. I would call something like Nascar a part of white culture, even though I know lots of White people don’t participate in it.
LikeLike
Jas0n,
Whether you acknowledge it (collective identity) out loud or not doesn’t mean it doesn’t exist. As Natasha said, White people show through their actions all the time that they consider themselves “white-aligned”. Just because they don’t say it out loud doesn’t make it any less obvious.
LikeLike
jas0n,
“Black people identify as black. Think of themselves as black. Recognize one another as black. (obviously among other things)”
Really?
I’m know some, possibly many do. But some blacks are raised “color blind” or otherwise not taught to place any particular emphasis on perceived race. These people are not rare at all, actually. I am one of them. Abagond was one of them. So you’re stretching things here. Just a bit.
“We are seen as a group by others but do not see ourselves as a group.”
Again, I disagree. To the extent that most won’t tend to think of themselves as a part of a united entity involving race, unless they are around others who are perceived to be of other races. I doubt this is unique to whites, since most people of a certain ethnicity live amongst others of their same ethnicity.
Anyway, I was more interested in these comments of yours:
“I’m just saying our culture is useless because it’s to vast. It has so many different meanings”
“No, American non-white’s are no more or less individuals than white people. But they do have less expansive cultures.”
LikeLike
Jasmin,
“Whether you acknowledge it (collective identity) out loud or not doesn’t mean it doesn’t exist. As Natasha said, White people show through their actions all the time that they consider themselves “white-aligned”. Just because they don’t say it out loud doesn’t make it any less obvious.”
I understand what jas0n is saying. And I agree, to a point. Most white people aren’t thinking “I’m white, thus…” But neither are most black people thinking “I’m black, thus…”. Most blacks I know are not racially conscious to that point, save a few self-proclaimed black nationalists and HBCU grads.
One thing I’ve noticed is that whites think that race is VERY important to blacks. They think blacks are always discussing race, always hyperfocused on it, that blacks automatically dislike them because they are white, etc. I’m guessing they get that idea from media like TV and internet, where racial issues are given more of an emphasis. Of course race is probably a lot more important to the average black American than it is to the average white American. But it is not some huge, overbearing idea that must color every thought and action they have.
LikeLike
“Whether you acknowledge it (collective identity) out loud or not doesn’t mean it doesn’t exist.”
OK. but what good is collective identity or shared culture or any of it if you don’t recognize or acknowledge it. If you don’t say “this is us, this is what we’re about” If you don’t feel like you have anything of significance in common with other members of your “collective” Than what is it? Where is it?
@ natasha
I don’t know maybe black American culture is just as expansive a white American culture. Maybe it’s just my perspective as a white person that makes it seem like whites have more cultural choices labeled as white stuff.
LikeLike
jas0n,
“I don’t know maybe black American culture is just as expansive a white American culture. Maybe it’s just my perspective as a white person that makes it seem like whites have more cultural choices labeled as white stuff.”
Probably. I’m not comfortable calling too many things particularly “white”, “black”, etc.
So, what do you label “white stuff”?
I’m curious to know, seeing as so many things I do seem to be labeled “white” by whites. A white friend commented that most of my choice baby names sounded like “white names”. When most of them don’t have W. European origins… Stop trying to claim everything, sheesh!
LikeLike
Well it seems like there are things that are almost exclusively white, like Nascar. Then there’s an ever expanding middle territory. Then things that are almost exclusively black, like naming your child Lebron.
LikeLike
I seriously have heard whites say that there is one black culture, with many “branches”, while claiming whites have a plethora of cultures that can’t be given a label.
I get hung up on this one a lot. I think a part of it is because there was far less influx of immigrants into the Black population for the last 150 years until just recently while white immigrants poured in. Together with enforced social segregation etc and you wind up with a population that is arguably more homogeneous in terms of shared history, origins, dialect than white americans as a whole. So Black feels like a more specific label, along the lines of WASP or Jew, something that refers not just to race, but ethnicity too. That doesn’t mean whites don’t have specific shared culture – they share culture related to how they look and how that gets them treated, which is huge.
LikeLike
I intended Jew to mean an ethnicity of white race in America, in case that wasn’t clear.
LikeLike
jas0n,
“Well it seems like there are things that are almost exclusively white, like Nascar.”
I’ve heard that one before.
Anything else? You remarked that white culture is more vast expansive than other cultures, so surely there is more than this.
“Then there’s an ever expanding middle territory.”
What’s this?
“Then things that are almost exclusively black, like naming your child Lebron.”
I was thinking I heard of a French guy with a similar name, and indeed, when Googled, that names comes up as French in origin. So there’s potentially hundreds+ other Lebrons who aren’t black.
I also can’t get with the thinking that anything which some blacks do = black culture. Most blacks I know have very ordinary, humdrum names like David, James, Ashley, or Tiffany.
Just to put this in practice, I chose some random black public figures, without thinking about it.
Here are their names:
Jeremiah (Wright)
Kelly (Rowland)
Aisha (Tyler)
Maxwell (Rivera)
Willow (Smith)
I don’t know, just given these first names… I would have a hard time guessing the person’s perceived race, except Aisha.
LikeLike
Right, because Aisha would obviously be Arab 😉
LikeLike
^Lol!
I know, it can be. I’ve know some non-black Aishas (not necessarily spelled that way). Yet most people would view it as a “black” name. I’m currently searching for baby names and I remember it showing up on one list as a common black American female name.
—
“I think a part of it is because there was far less influx of immigrants into the Black population for the last 150 years until just recently while white immigrants poured in… So Black feels like a more specific label, along the lines of WASP or Jew, something that refers not just to race, but ethnicity too.”
Interesting. I can see it from this vantage point. Thanks for pointing this out, since no one else has. It makes sense.
So, I guess people are excluding any blacks who aren’t multi-generational. But then, what about the various groups of multi-generational black Americans? Southern (Southeast) blacks are so very different from Northern (Northeast) blacks, in my experience; I would say that is a major division that should be taken into account. My black girlfriends from Manhattan relate much more to their white peers in NYC than to my black friends from South Carolina. I’ve never lived on the West coast for an extended period, but I imagine the same would apply, given those I know from that area.
LikeLike
I know not one but two (possibly more) white Aishas! (The spelling is different, but it’s the same name).
LikeLike
I would guess the person as black (and female) primarily for the spelling. But maybe I’ll amend this comment:
“I don’t know, just given these first names… I would have a hard time guessing the person’s perceived race, except Aisha.”
to:
“I don’t know, just given these first names… I would have a hard time guessing the person’s perceived race.”
🙂
LikeLike
Frank Talker – I salute you. Very succinct post/comment…
* applauds *
LikeLike
I suppose you can’t really get into a discussion about culture because in the end your just stereotyping. I don’t know if the 2 can be separated even though it seems like they should be.
LikeLike
But then, what about the various groups of multi-generational black Americans?
I think we naturally think of groups like a heirarchy or taxonomic tree, when it’s really more like a venn diagram. A multidimensional venn diagram with a gazillion circles and very fuzzy edges 😀 A lot of what Abagond seems to be talking about in the original post is whether the top of the taxonomic tree is American, with white and black as the next level down, or whether the top of the tree is black people and white people, with nationality as the second level. Thus the endless debate about silly things like whether one should say “Muslim American” or “American Muslim” for example. (I think Thad’s last comment was very good in this regard, and it’s unfortunate that he’s been banned.)
LikeLike
Maybe white people not seeing themselves as having “culture” shows a dissatisfaction with our own. White particularly American culture is so pervasive in the world that it has created an atmosphere of boring monotony and conformity. Flip the roles and you’d see the same sentiments among Blacks, Asians, or Hispanics. This longing for “culture” and denial of having one already by Whites is an expression of the alienation that is felt by dominant groups. Oppression hurts everyone, not just the oppressed.
LikeLike
Culture is an ambiguous term, and White Americans have about as much culture as Black Americans do, but it depends entirely on perspective. Class, region, and foreign ties are more clearly defined and tend to contradict the monolithic implications of racial cultures in the U.S.
LikeLike
White American Culture: Starbucks
LikeLike
Nah white American culture is weak and loose compared to some other cultures.
LikeLike
^ white American culture is a very strong and powerful culture, undoubtedly by far the strongest and most powerful in the world at the moment. It is so obvious as soon as you step outside the USA and then go back.
It is powerful, but also fragile in some respects. Time will tell if it has the properties needed to endure.
LikeLike
IMO, one reason whites do not perceive a strong cultural identity is that we, as a group or culture (which is a bit of a red-herring concept, but let’s go with it), have not generally been a minority/oppressed/threatened. We haven’t needed to rely on our culture as a means of preserving identity, unity or dignity. We have never appreciated it for what it is – a framework within which we live.
We take it for granted except in smug, academic, elitist ways. We analyse it, we make a product out of it, we make an industry out of criticising and deconstructing it. We barely notice it when we live it. The high art of the white world is for the rich. They deliberately make it inaccessible, incomprehensible, unaffordable. Even within “white culture” there is a ceiling above which only the privileged abide.
There is white street culture in my country, England, but it is largely derived from black influences. Sadly, the adoption of aspects of black culture does not always result in a deeper alliance. I have heard young white men speaking in the partially black-derived urban vernacular (sometimes known here as “chav-speak”) while wearing EDL t-shirts. EDL is an anti-Muslim organisation which claims, dishonestly, not to be racist.
LikeLike
Rick:
There is white street culture in my country, England, but it is largely derived from black influences. Sadly, the adoption of aspects of black culture does not always result in a deeper alliance. I have heard young white men speaking in the partially black-derived urban vernacular (sometimes known here as “chav-speak”) while wearing EDL t-shirts. EDL is an anti-Muslim organisation which claims, dishonestly, not to be racist.
A fellow English person. I agree with a lot of what you say here but, you forget with the young, it is often more about following fashion rather than conscience. Not saying its right but style sense often will out weigh common sense and we have to acknowledge that some might be ignorant of the realities of what some companies truly represent.
When I was growing up for example, GAP clothes were really popular. Recently my eldest child came home and mocked the younger sibling saying GAP now was know as Gay And Proud!
Also, you may or may not be aware, there is a gap an ocean wide between PoC from different ethnic backgrounds and that is regardless if they share varying shades of the same skin colour. This can extend to geographical gaps as well for example, someone from Africa and someone from the west indies might not necessarily get on just because they are both black. In my experience, the gap is much wider with South asians, and black. One asian person I talk to said that in part, the association with black people having been slaves made them feel that they were beneath them.
LikeLike
White Culture is to murder, rape, pillage, enslave for as long as possible while denying it. Everything that Europe spawned has done so and continue to do so. That’s what they’ve got in common. That’s what they are. That simple.
And “pop music”, which in reality, ain’t theirs either.
LikeLike
A little late to the discussion here… What I think Ms. Tuchluk fails to say it that we whites THINK we have no culture and therefore fail to see it in action. For whatever reason, the idea of shared history, experience, and group membership, in other words, many of the things that lead to the development of culture, are not salient to the white worldview. My guess is that in the “whitening” process that some people, mainly post-euroes, were allowed/forced to undergo to become part of the white race in the US made the idea of culture too complex for people. I see a white culture at work in the world that is a force for both evil and good. Perfect example: individualism. Individualism can act to separate us, to make us believe that each person creates her own situation when in fact the system may play a much bigger role in people’s outcomes. But individualism has been the gateway to strive for racial justice for me. My sense of outrage at begin lied to by the system and not wanting to allow it to happen again, my sense that I won’t let White Privilege define me as a person, even in its inescapability (just like I can’t escape gravity but that doesn’t define me as a person either) have roots in my individualism. I consider european-style art to be primarily culturally white- there’s some good stuff there. Shakespeare’s pretty culturally white. He’s no slouch. What’s more important than the high culture forms, however, are the worldview aspects of culture: individualism vs collectivism, power distance, gender role rigidity, perceptions of time. (can you say Hofstede?) Here’s one: I think the psychotherapeutic model has been used as a tool of oppression but racially unaware whites in the “helping professions” but is a culturally appropriate treatment for whites.
LikeLike
Shelly Tochluk cannot speak about “whiteness”. White is typically associated with Europeans. Shelly Tochluk is Jewish! Why doesn’t she talk about Jewish Privilege?
LikeLike
What is White Culture? It’s Western Civilization and the accomplishments of Europeans. Compare to that shit hole called Africa!
LikeLike
“Whiteness” is subjective.
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2015/03/02/biracial-twins-lucy-maria-aylmer_n_6787294.html?ncid=txtlnkusaolp00000592
LikeLike
^ King,
I think we will see that situation more and more often in the USA, esp. if both parents are multiracial. I am waiting for the triplet picture where one child looks black, one looks Chinese and one looks Irish.
Actually, I think that we actually DID see it 100 years ago too, but at that time it was not allowed to let multiracial people express their identity. They had to either be colored or pass as white.
LikeLike
Or the mother was simply burned as a witch.
LikeLike
@ jefe
But that is why I reject the idea of calling mixed people, “half-Black,” “half-White,” or “half-Asian.” Having one parent, each of different “races,” doesn’t mean that the child is split down the middle, 50% of one and 50% of the other. It’s genetics, not mathematics.
LikeLike
What people who label others exotic don’t understand is that to ourselves we are all what is “normal”.
LikeLike
@Zontas
Please tell us about your experiences growing up in PG county.
(https://abagond.wordpress.com/2015/03/25/prince-georges-county/)
LikeLike
That’s the problem with having vast quantities of people all over the globe sharing large aspects of your culture.
You tend to stop thinking of it as “yours” specifically as something that singles you out or defines you.
If everybody wears jeans and t-shirts, than that doesn’t mean much.
If everybody goes out to eat at Mcdonalds etc…….
What your culture is, is something like a skeleton or something that in many ways exists in all cultures across the globe.
If you watch TV and they watch TV, it doesn’t seem like something that is specifically american.
And of course; the whole “otherness” aspect to individuals looking at culture.
If you do it, that’s normal and not unique or “special” never mind that’s basically how it works for all cultures your apart of.
LikeLike
@V-4,
At the same time, there are many things that are distinctly white American and noted as such around the world. Stuff like Hollywood and Broadway and cowboys and white American English. Stuff that white Americans notice when they go overseas and say stuff like, “Oh, they have that here.” or better yet, “Where is the (distinctly American thing) ….?
People sharing bits of your culture does not mean that they think of it as their own.
And Americans overseas do recognize something as familiar and other things they perceive as foreign. And that is what it is all about.
LikeLike
Admittedly this is a topic I need to educate myself about, as a white person, so please excuse newbie assumptions and ignorance.
I think a lot of whites definitely can’t understand that they really do have a culture, because we think everyone else in the world lives in a very similar way to us. You know, celebrating most of the same holidays, festivals, etc. I caught myself doing this when I lamented Christmas to a friend and she told me that she knows it’s an important holiday to westerners but she didn’t get why I was that upset about it. For a moment I was kind of stunned and then my brain caught up with my emotions and slapped them back into place.
Many of us are fixated on getting in touch with our roots and heritage and I think it’s really an indication of family and social breakdown rather than lack of culture. I was friends with a girl who was fiercely proud of her strong, primarily Scottish heritage and the really strong family/cultural dynamics she had as a result of that. When I started to talk about my tiny bit of Scottish heritage, she dismissed it because it was too small and too far back. And I felt sad, bad and left out. And I know it wasn’t because I felt my cultural identity was being decided for me, it was actually because I’d really felt like she was saying I couldn’t experience what she does. And what I perceived she really experiences is strong bonds with her Scottish family, where as mine are non-existent.
I can only speak of myself and the white people I know, but none of us really participate in anything community driven or historical or cultural. There are the token holidays of course, but we’re immune to them and most of us seem to hate them. So it makes sense to me that we don’t feel like we have a culture, have decided that this is a white only problem and something to be sad about. Most of us are such a mutt mix of white cultures that even our precious heritage can’t tell us who to be or how to connect with people and holidays. So we romanticise other cultures and decide that we have less in comparison to them. (Though honestly, I bet if we tried to actually connect with people or hobbies and went to the local medieval fair and let ourselves enjoy it, we’d pull our heads out of our arses.)
The way I understand it is that while we feel like this is a white only problem, there are plenty non-white people in the world who struggle with cultural identity and think they have none. Partly because we took it away from them, partly because their bloodline is just as mixed and partly because they live a white lifestyle and white culture. Skin colour doesn’t equal culturally endowed. We white people need to stop pretending it does and get some therapy or something.
Just sayin’.
LikeLike
@NeedsEducatin
Do you travel around much? Even within the USA, are there environments in which you don’t feel anything special or unusual,
then feel them when you are in a different environment? Is there any circumstance where you feel a bit out of place, or where the other people seem to possess an awareness of things that you do not?
Amish are white Americans. But does “their” culture seem different to you?
There is some differences in “white” culture even within the USA. A white person who grew up in suburban Hartford, CT will feel something different among white people in Delta region of Mississippi or in Pocatello, ID, or Oxnard, CA, not to mention, Hilo, HI or the Aleutian Islands, yet miss something about “back home”.
I notice that white-identified Americans who feel they have no culture often are not pleased (or at least shocked) when their culture is given a name, eg, Anglo-American culture.
You will definitely notice it if you move outside the USA. If you find someone from “back home” whom you seem to connect with, it is because you share a culture with them. The culture that you identify with does not have to be the same as your great great grandparents, who gave up their culture so that you can enjoy the one you have now.
LikeLike
Click the links to this post and read them. That might explain.
LikeLike
what about code switching? kinda works both ways maybe?
LikeLike
@ Zontas
When the police take a break from brutalizing Black people, I will do a post.
LikeLike
Hi there,
This is my first post and I’m not as well written as many of the commenters here, but I am very interested in this topic as I (a white American) do not fully understand and feel somewhat disappointed in my own culture. This article insinuates that if I take interests in other cultures that I am over stepping a boundary as a white person. That makes me feel quite sad, because I wholeheartedly am a creature of love that desires unity and the end of racism, sexism, homophobia and the like, and when I take interests in things it is not to own, but to learn or connect to something greater. The article seems to want to restrict me somehow to what is perceived in America as “white culture” ie Starbucks and baseball. I do not like Starbucks and baseball, I do not like consumer driven culture. I think it is wrong. In America, that is “white culture” “valley girls”, “white girls”. I crave something deeper than that, than people that share through wealth. So I look to my roots- Native American, Irish, German. And I enjoy connecting to something deeper and the stories therein, but if I were to try to connect to Irish, German, or Native American culture I am limited by two things. One, they are very far or all but lost, and two they are exclusive and I would be seen as foreign even in my own blood, because I am perceived as a “white American”. In short, I do research and dig and have knowledge but no one to compare it with because 98% of white people in America have all but forgotten their ancestral background.This like the quote points out is maddening. I do not know in all honestly what culture I belong to, because everything I’m told is right for me to follow feels wrong, and everything I try to connect to outside that brings me spiritual knowledge, joy, and health I’m told is wrong too. Someone pointed out in a comment how American culture was built on many shameful things, like genocide. And I agree with that, and yet I’m still supposed to embrace it and stick to it? It’s so strange to me, my Irish/German heritage is accused of theft and murder, and my Native American side is the victim of both, yet I can’t be a part of either.
LikeLike
@ Rachel
You just made it very clear that you’re speaking from a White person’s perspective NOT from the perspective of a Native American.
LikeLike
Just answer the question, Michael.
LikeLike
Yes that was my point, I can’t speak from the perspective of a Native American, Irish person or German even though that is what makes up my DNA. which leads to my confusion.
LikeLike
Rachael said:
“This article insinuates that if I take interests in other cultures that I am over stepping a boundary as a white person.”
Your only overstepping a boundary if you take credit for another cultures achievements. American history as well as history written by the Soviets is white centric.
“That makes me feel quite sad, because I wholeheartedly am a creature of love that desires unity and the end of racism, sexism, homophobia and the like, and when I take interests in things it is not to own, but to learn or connect to something greater.”
Then you are blessed. But what needs to drive you to oppose oppression should not be guilt but anger and rage.
You have to start at zero. You have to accept that everything on this planet revolves around white supremacy. Everything you have been taught, all the false history, the views of your parents and the teachings of your religion need to be dumped out and reassessed.
“So I look to my roots- Native American, Irish, German. And I enjoy connecting to something deeper and the stories therein,”
Your roots are an artificial social construct. I took one of those 100 dollar DNA tests. I’m mostly Irish with some Native American. I’m also 3.5% “sub African”. But when I get up in the morning and look in the mirror I see a white man. I think like a white man, act like a white man and am 100% benefited because I’m a white man. That’s not artificial, that’s reality. All the DNA test tells me is that some of my ancestors were raped and some of my ancestors did the raping.
“In short, I do research and dig and have knowledge but no one to compare it with because 98% of white people in America have all but forgotten their ancestral background.”
That’s true but a lot of it was deliberate. The first thing European immigrants did was learn English, not teach their kids their mother tongue and embrace being white in America. Whites that owned slaves conveniently forgot they owned them. American history conveniently forgot to mention the full blown genocide of Native Americans. Never speaks of the fact that America has been in an armed conflict somewhere on the planet during 90% of its history. America pretends that it is not an Empire built on blood and a predatory culture.
American history books describe the Iroquois nation as a “war like and a fierce people”. But “war like” better defines American culture and is reflected in American history.
For me the American flag represents American culture. It represents the greatest expansion of oppression in the name of “democracy” the world has ever seen. It was Wildrow Wilson who said the Great war was to make the world “safe for democracy”. But what he was really alluding too was a world run by white people. The Wikipedia page on Wilson says this “He sought and received support from many in the black community, but his record on race as President has been criticized by recent scholars.” The fact is it was Wilson who segregated the White House bathrooms and pushed for Jim Crow laws. Wilson said that segregation “was an act of kindness”. America’s racist history is glossed over and “its all behind us now”.
When I think of America I think of droning brown people. I think of a two party system that’s supports a corporatacracy. I think of the industrial prison complex that houses 25% of the worlds prisoners. I think of Mac Donalds.
As a white American I can’t extract myself from its history. I can recognize the culture for what it is and oppose oppression whenever I have an opportunity to. In my personal interactions with people I treat everybody with mutual respect.
I’d rather know the truth then to be lied too or live in a lie.
LikeLike
Michael has it right. We ALL borrow or cross cultural lines. We ALL adopt and adapt things from other culture’s, often even altering them to fit our own perspective. The main point is to acknowledge that this is what was done.
True Cultural Appropriation usually follows this path:
1) Making fun and ridiculing another culture as inferior
2) Exotifying certain aspects of the overall “inferior” culture
3) Modifying the context of these cultural aspects to fit oneself
4) Claiming to have invented the end product
Simply saying, “Wow, I like that, and I want to do it too, wear it too, sing it too, say it too,” is not cultural appropriation… so long as you credit the source.
LikeLike
Exactly, but why must we have only that insidious excuse for a culture? Can’t we have anything else? Why is me benefiting from privilege evil and my fault? Why must my life revolve around poc for me to be just? Why are we never equal/ forgiven no matter how hard we work against racism? Why do the English, French, and Spanish get culture despite doing much worse deeds than America?
Why is it also disingenuous to revive my old world culture? Can’t THEY accept me? Why must poc say my culture is evil yet say i should never leave? Why don’t i get things for myself only, and why is all praise given to me wrong (if from whites) yet, poc should always be hateful towards me? Why can’t i be liked?
I know i can’t divulge myself from the colonial wrongs (so i know i must work to right them), but tell me why i shan’t be anything more than a lemon to be squeezed for poc usage or a pathetic villain. I know my life is better than theirs, but they have plenty who care for them.
I’m not baiting, trolling, or crying; i’m dead serious.
LikeLike
On second thought, i recant the stuff about poc not accepting me and the stuff about being only lesser and the stuff about only being a lemon.
LikeLike
Uriel, nobody has ever said that it is your fault. All we say is to at least acknowledge the fact, and work to combat racial favoritism to the the extent that you can. Is that so onerous?
Who is “We?” Are we talking about individuals or an entire race?
Are you looking for forgiveness from an entire race?
I cannot understand what it is that you are asking for?
LikeLike
Oh, forgot to mention, i take those back too. However, i do apologize for posting them in the first place. I always mention those two because people in sj work bar me from things because i benefit from privilege, and act like dicks to me because i benefit from privilege so they won’t forgive white people.
LikeLike
Uriel, what you are talking about is a personal situation with a particular group of people. You are not dealing with “The Black race” at your work, you are dealing with a small group of Black colleagues. They have not been elected to represent Blacks by any stretch of the imagination. Most of us here could probably tell you a similar story from work about a group of White coworkers who excluded us for some foolish racist reason. As I have said before, sane Black people do not blame you for what your grandfather might have said or done. But at the same time, the world its still dealing with racial strife. If you run into a pocket of it, my advice is to simply sidestep it and seek out the positive people who will accept you regardless of your color or culture of origin.
I say again, that is what we ALL have to do. We all have the problems from time to time.
LikeLike
There is so much white guilt here.
What we need is more some anger and indignation. We also need to take accountability for what we know and what we believe.
First step: Learn US history. Recognize that all we were taught in school is a mythological fairy tale.
Also, there is no requirement that everyone has to obey their cultural norms and standards. But don’t go around and deny there is anything such as “white” culture.
LikeLike
It is not that White Americans have no culture, but no culture not stolen or wrong. Why can’t we have GOOD cultures like European whites and poc? I can’t just magically assimilate into England (for instance), or revive what my ancestors gave up.
I know American and white history. I did do the research, which is why i hate/ will leave America forever , and why i must have a different, REAL culture.
LikeLike
“Do whites have a culture?”
Of course they do: Rape, murder and plunder!
LikeLiked by 1 person