Janet Mock (1983- ), writer and speaker, is one of the leading American voices for transgender women of colour. She has appeared in the Huffington Post, The Telegraph, NPR, MSNBC, the London Times and elsewhere. She used to be an editor at People.com. She started the #GirlsLikeUs campaign on Twitter. She took part of the It Gets Better Project.
Transgender means she was a he – one Charles Mock, in fact, the son of a native Hawaiian mother and a Black American father in Hawaii. At about age four it came to her that she was a girl in a boy’s body. It was something she could not shake. At five she put on a dress on a dare. It was a wonderful feeling – but the look on her grandmother’s face told her that she had crossed a line. She started hiding who she truly was, like playing with Barbie dolls behind closed doors.
By age eight her parents had split up. Her mother sent her and her brother to live with their father in Oakland, California. Her father noticed she acted like a girl and asked if she was gay. She was not sure what that meant, but she could tell her father thought it was something bad.
At age 12 she was sent back to Hawaii – and a good thing too. Hawaii in the 1990s was more accepting of transgender people. There were families, for example, that let their boys wear dresses and make-up. Her mother was accepting like that too. So when Mock began wearing women’s clothes to school at about age 15, her mother supported it. People at school called her names and never let her forget that she was “really” a boy, but they did not beat her up. The vice principal at school said she was making people “uncomfortable” and threatened to send her home if she kept wearing women’s clothes. None of that stopped her from being who she truly was.
Her boy’s body was starting to turn into that of a man. She hated how she looked. She was wondering if she should cut off her penis! Fortunately, because her mother supported her transgender identity, she was able to go to the doctor to get started on the right drugs. At age 18 she had a sex change operation. For the first time in her life she felt right in her body.
She went to the University of Honolulu and then went to New York to study journalism. In New York few knew she was transgender. But then in 2011 there was a string of murders and suicides of LGBT youths. As a writer she could not sit by in silence. She needed to be that person she never had growing up – someone who speaks up in public for transgender women of colour. She outed herself in the May 2011 issue of Marie Claire: “I Was a Boy”.
– Abagond, 2013.
Source: Marie Claire: “I Was a Boy” (2011).
Update (2018): In 2014 she gave a much fuller, less Disneyfied account of her trans coming of age story in “Redefining Realness”.
Update (June 11th 2018): She is now a writer, producer and director on “Pose” (2018- ), a television series that started last week on FX. It has not one but five characters who are trans women of colour – who are played by actual trans women of colour. And, with Mock, they are at least partly written by a trans woman of colour. Radical, I know. It is set in New York in 1987, the same time, place and slice of New York as “Paris Is Burning” (1990), one of Mock’s favourite films. More.
See also:
- Read her at: Huffington Post, xoJane, Tumblr, Twitter
- Redefining Realness
- trans women
Crafty bastards! It doesn’t even look anything like a man? I s there like, some type of system to more easily identify these types? I may be going to school in the BAY Area next year (finish up some stuff at a community college, then transfer to University of California system) and I hear that there are plenty of these types in that place.
So can we tell by looking at their feet? Man hands? Adam’s apple? What ?
LikeLike
satanforce: Why the hell do you care? Transgender women are women.
LikeLike
The Transgender people that we usually hear about are White so good for her being so open. I’m sure a lot of Black Transgender people, especially young people, are better off hearing her story.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Meh, I personally don’t agree with that, ” life style” for spiritual reasons.
I believe you should be what god, meant for you to be. Does that meant I hate gay or transgender people? Not at all, I simply don’t agree with it and that’s it.
I never understood why gay people, call everyone a bigot, just because they have personal and spiritual feeling about that life style.
I would talk to a gay person, deal with a gay person just like anyone else but it doesn’t mean, I agree with the life style they lead.
I was raised in a spiritual home but had a gay uncle, so homosexuality is nothing new to me, being I was exposed to it at a young age, then when I got old enough to form my own spiritual and personal opinion, I saw it for what it was in the eyes of a Christian.
I however, don’t go around preaching against or to gay people, they have to deal with that, when they met their maker and so will I for my sins.
I will say, if anyone ever asked me, do I believe homosexuality is right or wrong, I’d say I am personally against it for my spiritual beliefs, for that reason, only.
LikeLike
@Sondis
Saying you disagree with homosexuality is like saying you disagree with the sun. The sun like homosexuality has been around forever and will always be around. So, your disagreeing is a non-issue.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Mockery of natural law and the natural order is nothing to celebrate. Or do you disagree?
LikeLike
Mockery of natural law and the natural order is nothing to celebrate. Or do you disagree
If she didnt reveal that she was once a man no-one would be any the wiser. Some people dont ‘agree’ with people leading this lifestyle but no matter, they dont have to live as she tried to, full of inner turmoil.
The only time when people could potentially be ‘offended’ at transgenders for their life choices are the ones who may enter into an intimate relationship with them. I think there is an underlying fear that emerges when confronted with attractive transgenders such as Janet that there is the potential to become unwittingly duped. Yes, in her physical form she is a woman but the fact that she was born male would be an issue for some people but thankfully, not all.
LikeLike
I think gender and sex are two very different things. Gender is cultural, sociological. Sex is biological. So I think being transgender is psychological not biological. The same way I don’t think there are personality traits tied to being black or white, I don’t think there are personality traits tied to being female or male.
This analogy is probably flawed though since sex is real and race is not.
Transgender people are going to be inherent in a society founded on rigid sex roles, I think. However, we see feminine men and masculine women all the time who are quite happy with their respective bodies so I wonder if it is something else. Maybe it’s that some people embrace the learn to love yourself philosophy and others the change it if you don’t like it philosophy.
Disclaimer: I know absolutely nothing about transgender people. These are just thoughts that have been floating inside of my head. I was a complete tomboy growing up, always wanted to do what the boys were doing(still do, actually), but I never wanted a penis. I was pretty mad when I began my cycle, though.
LikeLike
All I can say is that Janet Mock is a very brave woman. This a very tumultuous journey she is on. God bless her and the others that are trying to travel and find their way.
LikeLike
I have learned not to judge. I have a feeling that it is hard and probably scary to know that you are different and knowing people will hate you for this very same being different. I hope Janet Mock is happy and just living her truth.
LikeLike
We have to admit Janet Mock is quite stunning. I’m sure she turns lots of heads.
LikeLike
I say good for her, from an adorable little boy to a brave and beautiful woman. How awesome is her mom, seriously.
LikeLike
Abagond, you are against gay/transgender lifestyles, are you not? I believe you said that you would be upset if one of your sons were gay, because you do not believe that lifestyle is morally acceptable.
Either way, I am glad you shared Janet’s story.
LikeLike
Its sad to see human being committing this kind of abominable acts. May God all our sins! Ameen.
LikeLike
Janet do y9ou get laid often? You are quite hot!
LikeLike
Trans people don’t live a ‘lifestyle’)and I hate that term), they live their lives.
LikeLike
@ Sondis
You pretty much summed up what I believe abou this particular matter. Like Mary Burrell said I try very hard not to judge others. As a Christian I to believe that our biological gender is a gift from God. However, I admit that I don’t have any issues with being a woman. I’ve never had a desire to be a man so I don’t understand the struggle Ms. Mock or others go through. It must be a terrible feeling to be at odds with one’s body.
LikeLiked by 1 person
@Satanforce
Lol! I’m sure you’ll be ok!
LikeLike
[…] Janet Mock (1983- ), writer and speaker, is one of the leading American voices for transgender women of colour. She has appeared in the Huffington Post, The Telegraph, NPR, MSNBC, the London Times … […]
LikeLike
[…] See on abagond.wordpress.com […]
LikeLike
One of the best looking women on the planet was born a man. Go figure.
LikeLike
based on what i have heard trannies say, they dont believe in God, or they think God is wrong. I dont believe in Trans-men or trans women. You are what your genitalia say you are. Penis, boy, vagina, girl. period.
LikeLike
oh, and by the way. there is no such thing as a man attracted to a trans woman. If both have penises, they are gay men. end of story. if both have vaginas, they are lesbians.
LikeLike
Janet Mock is seriously amazing. A major problem in the LGBT movement is the silencing of trans, genderless and genderfluid people, especially those of color, so her voice is very much needed.
LikeLike
his voice is not needed for the rest of the world. He is not “she” his DNA still says boy. He did not love himself enough to stay what he was made as. Pity
LikeLike
Karen – you have no idea what her karyotype is. For all you know, she could be XX. The penis=man, vagina=woman idea sounds simple, but what if you have both? What if your equipment is too small to be a penis but too big to be a clitoris?
LikeLike
anytime his parents named him Charles, he is a boy. else, how would they know what his sex was? He is a male. end of story. I dont care about XX this and XY that. He wants us to believe his lie. you can fall for it if you want; I choose not to.
LikeLike
@ Legion; I think what happened to Cece McDonald is a travesty of justice. I hope she gets her due day in the justice system. She was a victim of a hate crime and was trying to defend herself. I feel the justice system is treating her unfairly.
LikeLike
I was able to see Janet speak at my school’s Trans* Remembrance Day. She is a fantastic speaker and I was glad that I got the chance to hear her.
LikeLike
you were glad you got a chance to hear HIM. There is no Janet Mock, it is Charles. I bet if you did a dna test and looked under his skirt you would know what sex / gender he is.
LikeLike
Karen, your opinion is stupid and bigoted. Transgender and transsexual people is an reality, and not accepting that is an ignorance. Our chromosomes or what we have between our legs do not determine anything, but what between our ears does. What is in our brain has fundamental importance (gender identity). Trans people exist since humankind is on this planet and dismissing that is ignorance and stupidity. Being you religious you should know God made all things based on DIVERSITY. Nature is diverse. And God made trans people too. Finally, a troll as you who enters here to insult trans people must be called out
LikeLike
“Isabelle” if that is your real name: I don’t have to accept any demons if I dont want to. I dont believe trannies are human. They are made by the devil to destroy mankind. The reality is: Penis = male, vagina = female. not accepting that is ignorance. Charles was ashamed to be a homosexual, so he “created” “janet mock”, an invisible thing
LikeLike
I am a trans feminine person. Janet mock has made an excellent work in behalf of discriminated and downtrodden people. Based on what you saying about being human or not, I’d rather say prejudiced and hateful people are not human, but the real devil and evil. Janet isn’t doing harm to anyone, quite the contrary, but hateful and prejudiced people do. You’ve crossed all boundaries of sanity calling Janet (or Monica Roberts, leftytgirl Savannah, etc) demons. Your opinion would be risible if actual hateful monsters wouldn’t have this same thinking. Exterminationists demonize and dehumanize people they hate to discriminate and kill their victims freely. History is infested by this.
LikeLike
What the hell are you saying??? A lot of nothing. There are no such things as “Trans men/women” END OF STORY. there is no such it as “janet mock” or whatever the thing alleges to be. A lot of people want to be something they are not. it is not my fault. learn to live with and love yourself with the organs you are born with. Penis =male,vagina =female. END OF STORY.
I did not “dehumanize” you, you are a thing of the devil and a demon. Accept it
LikeLike
BTW, trannies hate themselves. it is their evil nature. their fault, not mine
LikeLike
@ Karen
1. “Trannies” is a slur, so you are dehumanizing them.
2. NO human being is an “it” or a “thing”. So again you are dehumanizing them.
LikeLiked by 1 person
It may seem like minor question: perhaps the vagina is an “organ” rather than a tract/orifice, but is it analogous to the penis?
I believe not.
It is the penis which is the male variant of the clitoris.
AFAIK, all human embryos possess the same Wolffian (and Muellerin) ducts that will end up as either clitoris or penis, depending on whether those ducts are bathed in male or female hormones during embryogenesis.
It’s a long time since I studied human anatomy, but if I recall rightly, the “vagina”, “uterus” and “fallopian tubes” in male anatomy ends up as the pouch of the prostate, or the prostatic utricle.
Believing that males-are-penis and females-are-vagina, that they are “true”, polarized and closed-ended equivalents, shows an investment in a false natural order that only exists to exclude and punish Janet Mock and women like her.
LikeLike
Haha Bulanik. Nice to have you back 🙂
LikeLike
I understand that the labia major is analogous to the scrotum.
Yes, indeed, it is because of the correspondence between the genitalia that many persons are born with “ambiguous” genitalia. For example, undescended testicles might make it difficult to tell the difference between the scrotum and the labia, esp. if the perineal fascia is not completely closed.
LikeLike
@ Karen
That is sex (biological), not gender (social). In Janet Mock’s case she got a sex change operation, so that makes her a she even in your book. In any case, “he” and “she” in English are not based on rude questions about one’s genitals or medical history, but on what someone seems to be. In Janet Mock’s case, she has a female name, so using “he” would only lead to confusion, while “it” is dehumanizing.
LikeLike
truth is truth. Charles’ DNA says he is a boy, not me.
LikeLike
Janet is not Janet. He is Charles. He needs to be honest and truthful about himself.
LikeLike
@balnick… or whatever…. what do you mean “women like her?” Charles is not, and never has been, a woman. It is a man playing dress up like on Halloween. He may wish he were female, but he is not. Even his DNA says so
LikeLike
I heard actor Neil Patrick Harris, himself a “member of LGBT, use the word Trannies. It must be ok and not dehumanizing
LikeLike
@ Karen
If Neil Patrick Harris is your guide then you should NOT use the word since he later apologized for using it:
http://www.advocate.com/politics/commentary/2012/01/27/oped-t-word-hasnt-changed-we-have
LikeLike
not trying to cause a conflict, but in school we were taught : he, she, it
If charles does not want to go by “he” it must be “it” because he is not a SHE
why is calling charles charles rude? His family named him that, so what is wrong with it?
LikeLike
Neil Harris is not my guide, but at the same time he should know what he is. Just like “Janet” claims to know what it is. Tranny should not be anything to be ashamed of
LikeLike
i am sorry you did not like my comment
LikeLike
So nasty just rot in Hell!
LikeLike
what’s so nasty? the truth?
LikeLike
@ abagond
Charles having a “sex change” does not make him a girl in my book. Don’t ever tell me what I know to be true. If GOD changed charles’ DNA from male to female and changed his body to a REAL girl’s then he might be a girl. Just because charles cut his penis off, molded a vagina with play dough, and tacked it on with crazy glue does not make him a female. It makes him a male without a working penis. Even with a “sex change” he does not have a working vagina. Does he have a womb? can he get pregnant? does he have a period? If the answer is yes, then he might be 1% female. If the answer is no, then he is not a female and never was one.
Now I know I will be blocked from this site because I am telling the truth, and the day you do that is the day I know you are all admitting I am right. Who the heck determines what is sex and what is gender? The trannies? I, born a REAL woman because God loved me enough to do so, determines what a female is and isnt. No man can tell me what a female is.
Until charles has to buy tampons and USE them personally, he will never be a woman. He is a man who is a homosexual, if he loves men. If he loves women sexually, then I’ll bet he still has the penis. More than that, I heard a lot of those trannsexuals don’t change the bottom part of their anatomy anyway. Why is that?
If you want to have free discussions, then allow me to say what I know to be true; allowing one sided discussions says a lot.
LikeLike
waiting for my comment to be cut…why is that? I dare you to leave it there.
TELL THE TRUTH
LikeLike
Wow Karen, I have rarely time travelled in my life but you do take me back. You should charge for that ride.
LikeLike
I wanted to share a little perspective with the commenters on this story. First of all, Hawaii is the most ethnically & culturally diverse state in the nation: per the 2010 Federal Census, 25% of the state’s population self-identify as being 2 ethnicities or more (compared to approx. 2.8% nationwide). There is a rich cultural & spiritual collection from every place in the world, living in harmony & peace. There’s a general acceptance & tolerance for differences, & a celebration of our diversity. 2. Many of the cultures present in Hawaii have a tradition of recognizing more than two genders; Polynesians, & some Asian & African cultures have a third gender. They usually are found in spiritual/religious/sacred tradition roles in their culture, & are held in high esteem. So, individuals who occupy the “space” between the two genders found in Western society are welcomed in Hawaii. 3. An important reason for the type of acceptance of diversity found in Hawaii can be explained in some part by its geographic isolation: Hawaii is located 2,562 miles from Los Angeles, California, & 2,336 miles from Adak, Alaska (the closest states). In the event of a natural disaster, war, or even shipping strikes, Hawaii is basically on its own for survival. Historical events (tsunamis, hurricanes, bombing of Pearl Harbor, shipping strikes) have proven time & time again that when faced with challenges, the people will come together & help each other survive, without consideration of their ethnicity or gender or religion or language or political affiliation. When people are in that type of situation, your differences are unimportant, survival is critical. So, when one learns this, the differences are as important as enjoying a buffet of every wonderful thing in life. 4. So, if someone’s has prejudice or biases, and feel intolerance for different beliefs/religions/ethnicities/nationalities/sexual orientation, then Hawaii’s really not the place for you. In Hawaii, Janet (& people like her) are accepted & cherished & respected & loved for herself, not what others try to define her as, or who someone else wants them to be; they’re loved for just being. That’s called a culture of unconditional love & acceptance.
LikeLike
@ Haunani Martin
But once every so often when I was out there with a family friend and now inlaw like 20 yrs back I did hear ‘Pappolo’ in our direction. The ironic thing is many African Americans don’t look too different from some of these Polys give or take so it is irrelevant in most cases. Hawaii has its issues that make it very unwelcoming to new comers in areas outside and within tourist boundaries. I’ve experience and learned first hand. Many Asians, particularly SouthEast, are going through shit in the mainland in terms of social treatment so we don’t need to be scrutinized that way on Hawaii neither.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Update: In 2014 she gave a much fuller, less Disneyfied account of her trans coming of age story in “Redefining Realness”:
https://abagond.wordpress.com/2018/01/27/janet-mock-redefining-realness/
LikeLiked by 1 person
Update: She is now a writer, producer and director on “Pose” (2018- ), a television series that started last week on FX. It has not one but five characters who are trans women of colour – who are played by actual trans women of colour. And, with Mock, they are at least partly written by a trans woman of colour. Radical, I know. It is set in New York in 1987, the same time, place and slice of New York as “Paris Is Burning” (1990), one of Mock’s favourite films.
Her interview on BUILD:
(https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WmzTxFXNs8c)
LikeLiked by 1 person
I watched some episodes of Pose on demand on the FX channel. The Ball culture is interesting.
LikeLike
@ Mary
I saw part of the second episode. It was pretty good. The diner scene (“I accumulate”) took it above mere soap opera. And out-of-focus on the walls of the nail salon were Patrick Nagel pictures, which I have not seen since the 1980s – an attention to detail I did not expect. But it was hard for me to enjoy the gay love story part.
LikeLiked by 1 person