Tue 6 May 2008
The pure white woman stereotype
Posted by abagond under 1800s, 1900s, America, race, stereotypes, white people, white women
The pure white woman stereotype was a picture that white Americans had in their heads about white women. It pictured them as being pure in terms of both sex and race. It was the main excuse given for Jim Crow, the laws and customs that kept down black people for a hundred years after they were freed as slaves.
Even today the stereotype lives on in a weakened form, making white Americans uncomfortable when they see a black man with a white woman.
The pure white woman determined how whites looked at blacks. If white women were pure, then black men were the threat. Thus the black brute stereotype, which saw black men as savages. And if white women were pure, then black women were not. Thus the Jezebel stereotype, which saw black women as easy and loose.
This picture of white women had such force that a black man could be killed just for being too friendly with a white woman. Thus the lynchings, where black men hung dead from trees.
At the heart of all this was the raw fear in the hearts of white men that black men would take all of “their” women - meaning the white women. They thought black men were better at pleasing women in bed. So they had to be stopped.
They were stopped in three ways:
- White men kept the races apart with Jim Crow laws, laws backed up by lynchings.
- White men made sure that most black men were kept poor. making them undesirable to white women as husbands.
- The One Drop Rule meant that any children a white woman had by a black man would be black too.
Black men were kept from white women, but white men continued to rape black women without consequence.
So, in the name of keeping white women pure, to keep them up on that pedestal, blacks were kept down.
But white women were kept in their place too, even if it was up on a pedestal somewhere closer to the angels.
The American magazines and religious books of the 1800s told white women that to be good and pure they should leave the dirty business of running the world to their husbands. So no need to vote. They were told that making beds was much better for them than reading books, which would only fill their heads with the wrong ideas. And so on.
The Jim Crow laws came down in the 1950s and 1960s. By 1967 black men could marry white women anywhere in the country.
But even now some white people are still not comfortable seeing a black man with a white woman. White women are still held up as more beautiful than anyone and more morally upright, despite “Girls Gone Wild” and other things. And when a white woman is missing it can be on the news for days and days, while missing black women never seem to make the news for some reason.
See also:
Tue 6 May 2008 at 21:22:59
Good post yet again Abagond.
With the history beihind the pairing of bm/ww, why do you think they are only number two behind wm/aw?
Why are so many bm willing to overlook the Emit Tills’ of this country in order to marry a ww?
Wed 7 May 2008 at 10:52:11
Thanks. That is a good question. I think Jim Crow made such pairings more likely not less because they were forbidden. The forbidden fruit thing. In addition to what you always hear about white women being easier to get along with (= dominate?) and how they are held up as the height of beauty.
Wed 7 May 2008 at 16:24:45
Hello Abagond, I’m back after burying my grandmother down South. I’m still mourning the death of my grandmother. Now her daughter/my aunt is currently ill because of the shock of her mother’s death.
Thank you so much for posting this important article on the “pure white woman ideology.” It’s part and parcel of American culture that the ideal that upper middle class/upper class white anglo woman be on the pedestal above Blacks. It’s still the case.
Steph
Thu 8 May 2008 at 02:29:11
Abagond I agree with you about the forbidden fruit.
Thu 8 May 2008 at 11:55:11
Stephanie, welcome back! And thank you for the links to articles you sent me. They helped me write this post.
Thu 8 May 2008 at 17:44:31
Abagond,
You’re welcome. The ideology of pure white womanhood requires the subordination of Blacks in order for white supremacy to go on as it has been for centuries. It’s still with us today in the form of unfair media treatment of Black and White women.
What say you?
Steph
Thu 8 May 2008 at 22:55:10
It is crystal clear from the media in America that white women are seen as more beautiful than black women and their lives far more valuable.
Fri 9 May 2008 at 01:35:58
The “allure” of the forbidden fruit:
The media, government, society, and popular culture decree the white woman as being the ultimate in human beauty, femininity, virtue and in moral superiority, ergo, they are forbidden by custom to mingle with “less desireable” elements of society and from the realms of business/politics/professions/academia/entertainment, for these things would sully what virtue upper middle/upper class white women have by virtue of their purity/femininity/moral superiority.
Black men and women are decreed as threats to the “sanctity” of “holy white womanhood”. Black women are competition to white women, i.e. the potential take their men away, while Black men could take away their “virtue”. Therefore, the white man have to protect his women from Blacks of both genders. In order to do so, segregation, formal and informal, media and cultural propaganda, discrimination, lynchings, prisons, etc. are utilized to this end.
Black men weren’t suppose to be familiar with white women on the pain of death. They weren’t suppose to look at posters of white female celebrities during Jim Crow. While thousands of Black women were violated during that period of time.
Abagond, white women, black men and black women didn’t invent the ideology of white womanhood. It’s white men who invented it in order to oppress Blacks, keep them forever subordinate, maintain inequality, and to cover up his guilt.
Stephanie B.
Fri 9 May 2008 at 03:07:09
I think what drove Jim Crow were two things:
First, whites did not want to slip to the bottom of society after the slaves were freed.
Second, white men were afraid of losing “their” women to black men.
So they changed up the rules to keep blacks at the bottom.
All these ideas about white women that still live on grew out of that.
Fri 9 May 2008 at 03:17:44
Stephanie: Thanks for your comments. They are making me go back and make the post better.
Sat 10 May 2008 at 00:09:54
Abagond,
You’re welcome.
Steph
Thu 15 May 2008 at 19:52:38
First, I would like to say great post. It is a shame that the ideal standard of beauty in America can still be attributed to white women. The problem with this idea is, so many white women seek surgery in order to have characteristics that are more common amoung black women (collagen insertions, breast enhancements, buttocks uplifts/injections). The list could probably go on and on. Each person needs to be happy with the body they were born with. Black women and all women must first learn to see their inner beauty before any man will see their true beauty.
Fri 16 May 2008 at 00:17:45
Thanks. I have written about quite a few beautiful women and one thing that keeps coming up is that true beauty starts from the inside, not the outside.